top of page

When Delay Becomes the Outcome

Nov 5
6 min read

OPINION / COMMENTARY | Power & Accountability Thursdays — Episode 02


By Chris Manzano | Prepared November 5, 2026; sources refreshed November 12, 2026


I believe the law should give every person a fair hearing. But a fair hearing that arrives too late can become something very different. A business can survive another month of uncertainty when it has reserves and a legal team. A worker who needs a paycheck, a tenant trying to stay housed, or a family contesting a bill may not have the same ability to wait.


That doesn't prove anyone intentionally caused a delay. It does raise a question I care about: when the process takes longer than an ordinary person can withstand, does the system offer the same practical protection to everyone?


In the previous installment, I wrote about wealth and the ability to influence institutions. In this installment I want to isolate one mechanism: time. Not the sensational accusation that every motion is a trick, but the ordinary calendar of notices, responses, documents, hearings and decisions—and who bears its cost.


Conceptual Miami Vice illustration of a sundial and accessible path in a fictional South Florida civic courtyard; not a real courthouse or case.

The clock is part of the case


The federal judiciary's report for the year ending September 30, 2025 gives us a useful but limited benchmark. For U.S. district-court civil cases, the median time from filing to disposition was 15.6 months, compared with 13.7 months in the prior fiscal year. Those are national figures for cases that ended during the reporting year, not a promise that any individual dispute will last that long. The mix of large multidistrict litigation proceedings can move the measure considerably. [1]


I don't quote that statistic to accuse a particular judge, court or litigant. I quote it because time belongs in any serious conversation about justice. A case may be decided correctly and still require months of rent, transportation, attorney fees, missed work, document collection or financial uncertainty from the people involved.


Some costs are shared by both parties; some fall more heavily on the party with less savings, less bargaining flexibility or no lawyer. And sometimes the financially weaker party is a small business facing a well-resourced individual, not the other way around. The test should be the actual burden, not a stereotype about who is plaintiff or defendant.


An equal rule can carry an unequal burden


Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 1 states the aim of a just, speedy and inexpensive resolution. Rules 16 and 26 give federal courts tools for managing schedules and making discovery proportional to what a dispute actually needs. These are rules for federal civil proceedings, not universal deadlines for every state or local case. [2]


Here's the practical problem I see. Each request for another document, each extended response deadline and each hearing that moves to another date may have a defensible explanation. But a series of individually reasonable steps can still produce a crushing cumulative cost. The person with a cushion may keep paying for the process. The person without one may settle, abandon a claim, accept worse terms or simply run out of room to maneuver.


That is my inference about a possible mechanism, not proof that any particular opposing lawyer acted improperly. A motion might be necessary. An appeal might be meritorious. A delay might be caused by judicial staffing, a complex evidentiary record or an emergency unrelated to either side's wealth. We should measure and investigate those differences before assigning responsibility.


The central question is not whether somebody used the procedure. It's whether the system can distinguish necessary procedure from avoidable friction—and whether it can respond before the burden itself decides the dispute.


What the access-to-justice research does tell us


The National Center for State Courts' 2015 Landscape of Civil Litigation examined 925,344 non-domestic civil cases disposed in a 2012–13 period across 152 courts in 10 urban counties. At least one party lacked a lawyer in more than three-quarters of those cases. That is historical evidence from a selected study population—not an estimate of Miami-Dade's current caseload or every American lawsuit. [3]


There is also a much older randomized study worth treating carefully. In a New York City Housing Court legal-assistance experiment, published in Law & Society Review in 2001, 22% of tenants receiving counsel had final judgments against them, versus 51% of those without the assigned representation. The study also found that representation could increase days to final judgment, while reducing some motion activity. [4]


Those results don't tell us how any Florida case would end in 2026, and legal representation isn't a magic guarantee. They do challenge a simplistic choice between fairness and speed. More time can be essential when it allows someone to present a real defense. Less procedural churn can be valuable at the same time.


The question should be which delay protects the merits, and which delay merely consumes a person's capacity to participate?


The best argument against going too fast


There is a serious objection to my concern: faster isn't automatically fairer. People deserve notice, access to evidence, an opportunity to contest allegations and time to prepare. Courts must handle complicated records, and an honest litigant may need an extension to locate witnesses or fix a mistake. Appeals can correct actual legal errors. Even a decision that feels painfully slow to one side may reflect a required safeguard for the other.


I agree with that objection. I don't want officials rushing claims, preventing legitimate appeals or using accusations of “delay tactics” to punish unpopular parties. Nor do I want deadlines that favor organizations with sophisticated legal departments because they can respond instantly while an unrepresented person cannot.


A court's independence matters too. Transparent timeliness goals should help judges manage workloads, not pressure them toward a particular political outcome or a predetermined winner. And procedural sanctions require an established legal basis and appropriate notice—not somebody's opinion that a wealthy litigant has waited long enough.


In fact, the legal-aid experiment is a warning against a one-number solution: an intervention that improves participation can lengthen a case. Counting only elapsed days could mislabel that as failure.


Accountability that measures the right things


I would start with a modest, testable approach rather than a promise to redesign every court overnight.


First, courts could publish understandable, privacy-conscious time measures by case category: how long cases wait for an initial response, a first meaningful hearing and disposition. Reports should separate ordinary proceedings from complex or consolidated matters, disclose data limitations and avoid exposing sensitive individuals or protected filings. We should be able to see where the waiting happens instead of treating one median as the whole story.


Second, judges and court administrators should have the capacity and tools to manage schedules, narrow irrelevant discovery and explain unavoidable changes. Speed without adequate staffing and legal help just shifts costs to the people least able to absorb them. Legal-aid funding and accessible instructions matter; a better website alone will not replace a lawyer when one is needed.


Third, proposals for expedited handling should focus on a demonstrated risk that delay will destroy a meaningful remedy—without assuming either side is dishonest. An eviction, lost wages or interrupted access to essential services may warrant a different timetable from a large commercial accounting dispute. But actual priorities must follow law, evidence, impartial standards and the rights of both parties.


Finally, I'd look beyond the speedometer. Did each side understand the process? Were important claims heard on their merits? How often did procedural changes require repeat appearances? Were urgent remedies actually usable? Did appellate review expose errors? Those measures are harder to collect, but a faster docket is not the same thing as more justice.


Time should not be a hidden price of a right


I am not arguing that private resources should be capped, that every wealthy person abuses litigation or that every poor litigant is correct. Legitimate success deserves protection. So does due process for someone accused of wrongdoing. An accountable institution has to defend both principles at once.


My concern is simpler. If a person can technically demand a hearing but cannot afford to survive the wait, the right exists on paper more comfortably than in real life. We should be able to examine that gap without accusing individual judges or litigants of misconduct based on their bank balances.


For the next conversation, I want to ask something measurable: Where in a civil case do ordinary people lose the most time and capacity—and which safeguard would reduce that loss without weakening the other side's right to be heard? That's the kind of accountability I'd like us to build.


Personal opinion and general civic/legal-system education, not individualized legal, mortgage, investment or tax advice. Court procedures vary by jurisdiction. Sources checked November 12, 2026; statistics and experiments describe their stated historical populations, not current local outcomes.


Sources and further reading


1. Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts, U.S. District Courts — Judicial Business 2025, fiscal year ended September 30, 2025: https://www.uscourts.gov/data-news/reports/statistical-reports/judicial-business-united-states-courts/judicial-business-2025/us-district-courts-judicial-business-2025


2. U.S. Courts, Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, current rules page, amended in 2025; Rules 1, 16, 26: https://www.uscourts.gov/forms-rules/current-rules-practice-procedure/federal-rules-civil-procedure


3. National Center for State Courts, Hannaford-Agor, Graves and Miller, The Landscape of Civil Litigation in State Courts, 2015, 2012–2013 case cohort: https://scholarship.law.wm.edu/facpubs/2390/


4. Seron, Van Ryzin, Frankel and Kovath, The Impact of Legal Counsel on Outcomes for Poor Tenants in New York City's Housing Court: Results of a Randomized Experiment, Law & Society Review 35(2), 2001: https://www.researchwithrutgers.org/en/publications/the-impact-of-legal-counsel-on-outcomes-for-poor-tenants-in-new-y/

Recent Posts

See All
When Does a Housing Grant Become a Home?

A Miami project shows why funding, construction and lasting affordable occupancy deserve separate scorecards. Chris Manzano puts MMT's resource test against actual housing delivery.

 
 
 

Comments


How Would You Like to get started?

Whether you’re ready to apply or just have questions, choose the option that works best for you. I’ll take it from there.

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
bottom of page